Updates

◦ 🤗 Hey there y’all Gatsby’s 🏈Fans In Cyber Land 🖐Annie says it’s Football 🏈 Free Saturday night Yepper 🤙 The Secret decoder Words🤔 Finish the lyrics of
◦ The all time Classic 1940’s
◦ 50’s Song , I Found My Thrill on 🤔🤔🤔 and get a Free Cheese Pizza 🍕 when U order any Two Pizzas 🍕...

Read More

- [ ] 🤗 Hey there y’all Gatsby’s 🏈Fans In Cyber Land 🖐Annie says it’s Football 🏈 Free Saturday night Tailgate Party Yepper 🤙 The Secret decoder Words🤔 What does a Turkey 🦃
- [ ] Say Gobble Gobble 😂
- [ ] , and get a Free Cheese Pizza 🍕 when U order any Two Pizzas 🍕 🍕 Yepper 😂 or ...

Read More

Hey there y’all Gatsby’s fans in cyber Land, Annie says It’s Free Pizza 🍕 Saturday , Buy any two Lg pizzas 🍕 and get a Lg Cheese FREE Yepper , if U can Finish the last word of the lyric from the 1961 Hit song by Ricky Nelson 🤔 Hello Mary Lou Goodbye
——-🤔 don’t forget half baked ...

Read More

🍕😉 Hey there y’all Gatsby’s fans in cyber Land It’s two toppen Thursday 🍕🍕 Yepper
🍕 Annie says check ya decoder ring 👌 For today’s secret 🤫🤭 In The 1941 Classic Movie 🎥 Staring Bob Hope , Bing Crosby On The Road to Zanzibar , Name the Female costar 🤔 And get Two FREE toppins on a...

Read More

🍕🍕🍕 GO BUCKS
🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈 Gatsby’s PIZZA

O H O O 😂

🏈

◦ 🤗 Hey there y’all Gatsby’s 🏈Fans In Cyber Land 🖐Annie says it’s Football 🏈 Free Saturday night Tailgate Party Yepper 🤙 The Secret decoder Words🤔 What was the Iconic Name given to The 1924 undefeated Notre Dame’s Backfield , and get a Free Cheese Pizza 🍕 when U order any Two Pizzas 🍕...

Read More

🍕🤗 Hey Y’all Gatsby’s Fans In Cyber Land 👋 Annie says it’s Fifty Off 😆 FRIDAY IfU can
Tell Annie what was Bobby Darin doing 🤔, when He was singing 🎤 His 1958 Classic Song Splish Splash 🥴 y’all get Half off your second Pizza
W hen U buy any Lg one item Pizza 🍕
😲Don’t forget half b...

Read More

🍕😉 Hey there y’all Gatsby’s fans in cyber Land It’s two toppen Thursday 🍕🍕
🍕 Annie says check ya decoder ring 👌 For today’s secret 🤫🤭 Name the make and caliber of the RifleAnnie Oakley used
In Her Wild West Show And get Two FREE toppins on any Lg Pizza 🍕 😂
We know offer Curbside...

Read More

◦ 🤗 Hey there y’all Gatsby’s Fans In Cyber Land 🖐Annie says it’s Football 🏈 Free Saturday night Tailgate Party Yepper 🤙 The Secret decoder word 🤫 What Year did Archie Griffin Win his first Heisman trophy 🤔 and get Two Free Cheese Pizza ‘s 🍕 when U order any Two Pizzas W/one item ea...

Read More

Testimonials

a year ago
What a great spot! We ordered a pizza and some cheesy garlic bread for takeout, and it was ready super fast. The pizza was delicious, with crispy crust and plenty of cheese and the garlic bread had extra sauce for dipping. The staff was SO kind and went out of their way to accommodate us, and I wish we would have found this place sooner during our trip. The inside is really cute - I love their decorations. If you’re going to get the garlic bread, definitely get it with cheese! You won’t regret it.
- Anna B
3 months ago
If you are in the Bonita Springs area and our originally from the Midwest, specifically Ohio, this pizza is a must try. The owner Greg is a very humble guy. He talked with me while my pizza was being prepared. Great pizza with a great story.
- Tracy B
10 months ago
Great place, great pizza, great people. Amazing people. My better half's card would not run. She told Mr Gatsby she would retrieve another card or get cash. He told her not to worry and just comeback next day. Unfortunately this was Saturday we forgot Sunday and they were not open until following Thurs. She finally did make it back in to take care of it and he still couldn't of been nicer. GREAT PEOPLE.
- chris w

Gatsby's Pizza Menu Items

One Size Fits All
14" Pizza w/Sauce + Cheese
$17.95
14" Pizza w/Oil, Garlic & Cheese
$17.95

Toppings
(Pepperoni, Sausage, Chicken, Ham, Meatball, Mushrooms, Onions, Tomato, Green Pepper, Mild Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Pineapple)
$3 Meat /$2  Vegi's Per Topping

Margherita
(Mozzarella, Provolone, Blended Cheese, Tomato, Fresh Basil, Garlic, And Olive Oil)
$20.95

Chicken Ranch
Blended Cheese, Marinated Chicken, Specialty Ranch
$20.95

"8" Pizza w/Sauce & Cheese
$8.95
Toppings-$0.50

Any 5 Item Pizza Special
Special $26.95

(You Can Always Order Our Pizza's Half Baked, No Cut, To Reheat Later On Your Grill, Or In Your Oven)

Jackie's Homemade Lasagna
Lasagna W/Two Pieces Of Garlic Bread & Small Salad
$16.95

Buckeye Bites
Half A Pound Of Baked Breaded Morsels Rolled In Our Secret Breading. Mmm Yummy With Just A Little Bite (hehe) *side of ranch included*
$8.95

House Salad
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Green Pepper, Banana Pepper, Cheese, Pepperoni, Grandma's Light Italian
Sm-$7.95 Lg-$10.95

Bottled Water-$1.50
Any Soda - $2.50
Bud Lite(NA)-$2.50
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

***** DELIVERY Websites*****
BiteSquad
https://www.bitesquad.com/food/gatsbys-buckeye-pizza-/26336

GrubHub
https://www.grubhub.com/restaurant/gatsbys-pizza-4836-bonita-beach-rd-bonita-springs/1182844?proof=true

UberEats
https://www.ubereats.com/en-US/fort-myers/food-delivery/gatsbys-pizza/1X_jPWoTSv2Ha17aE41pHg/

Contact Us

Contact

Call now
  • (239) 785-0122

Address

Get directions
4836 Bonita Beach Road Southwest
Bonita Springs, Florida 34134
United States

Business Hours

Mon:Closed
Tue:Closed
Wed:Closed
Thu:4:00 – 9:00 PM
Fri:4:00 – 9:00 PM
Sat:4:00 – 9:00 PM
Sun:Closed
Contact Us
✕
Message sent. We'll get back to you soon.